Do the 0DTE opening rules in Zero to Profit, Vol. 1 make money on real option quotes?
Do the book's opening-gap rules for same-day SPY and QQQ options make money when they are traded mechanically at real bid and ask quotes?
No. Both ways of trading the book's opening rules lost money. Buying the first out-of-the-money same-day SPY or QQQ option at the ask and selling at the bid, 230 trades from January 2023 to August 2024 at one contract each, lost $1,231.50 under the book's plan (half sold at 10:55, half at 13:00; mean return on premium -2.57%, 35.2% of trades profitable) and $558.00 when everything was sold at 10:55 (-1.25%, 37.8% profitable). Both plans also lose money in dollars with no commissions at all (the sell-everything-at-10:55 plan's mean return then is about zero, +0.06%) and at double commissions. The book's stated win rates of 60% to 80% for its six setups sit outside the 95% interval of every setup's measured hit rate (arm A's options won 30% to 39% of the time in each). Buying the same options every morning with no signal did about as badly (-2.64% on calls, -6.24% on puts, -4.44% on both), so there is no sign the rules choose better trades; this comparison is a description, not a tested result. This tests the book's mechanical rules as written, not its discretionary judgement, and a result for this window only.
Backtested by QS Research
Pre-registration
Pre-registered before any quotes for the counted window were read, and approved on 2026-11-06. The book's opening gap-and-move rules pick calls or puts on SPY and QQQ same-day options. The trigger is checked on the 09:55-09:59 ET bars: a new session low for calls, a new high for puts. The contract is the first strike out of the money. Entry is at the ask of the first usable quote from the minute after the trigger, within 5 minutes (about 09:56-10:05 ET). Exits are at the bid. Two exit plans are judged: half at 10:55 and the rest at 13:00, or everything at 10:55. An entry quote with a spread wider than 25% of the mid is refused and counted as a skip. Entered trades are never dropped: a missing exit is priced at a later bid or at zero. The verdict needs positive P&L and a positive weekly-bootstrap lower bound, at a family of 2 trials, with the deflation line against every QS Research trial also shown. The counted window is January 2023 to August 2024. The later stretch from September 2024 is reported but not counted, because an earlier QS Research test already looked at it. A 120-session holdout stays sealed.
Registered 2026-11-06Amendments
- 2026-11-06 Schedule only: results due by 2026-11-20; the holdout ends no earlier than 2027-05-03. No rule changed. approved: Approved 2026-11-06; schedule only, no rule changed
- 2026-11-13 Record only, before any quote for the counted window was read: the runner, the contract selection, the data fetch and the snapshot ids. No rule, window, arm, threshold, fill or cost changed. approved: Recorded before the counted run and reviewed
- 2026-11-13 Before any quote was read: each arm is judged on the weekly bootstrap lower bound at one-sided 0.05 divided by 2 (the 5% bound shown beside it), and strikes are read as written. approved: Approved 2026-11-13, before any quote was read
A holdout sample is sealed: its results stay unread until the study is final.
Trials · 2 trials · 0 passed · judged at N = 2 trials; 1935 trials run in total
| Trial | Verdict | |
|---|---|---|
| A, the book's plan (half sold at 10:55, half at 13:00): total -$1,231.50, mean return on premium -2.57%, hit rate 35.2%, weekly bound -0.1254 | FAIL | counted |
| B, everything sold at 10:55: total -$558.00, mean return on premium -1.25%, hit rate 37.8%, weekly bound -0.1290 | FAIL | counted |
Limitations
- Only the book's mechanical rules are tested (the opening gap and move table, the new-extreme trigger, the first out-of-the-money strike and the two exit plans). Its discretionary judgement, its charts, its averaging down and its sizing are not.
- One contract per trade, bought at the ask and sold at the bid of 1-minute quotes, with $0.65 per contract per side. A real fill inside the minute could differ. Position sizing is shown only for illustration: at the book's 20% of the account per trade, three $1,500 accounts lost about half of their value in 63 sessions, and one $4,500 account about two thirds, in a resampling of these trades, which is not a tested result.
- The counted window is January 2023 to August 2024 (418 sessions per symbol). Only the strikes, windows and fills as the pre-registration states them were tested; a strike a full dollar further out was not.
- The test is not powerful enough to rule out a small edge: with 79 weeks it could only detect a weekly mean return on premium of about 0.17 to 0.23. It shows these exact rules lost money in this window, not that no variation of them could win.
- Slices of the result (by year, calls versus puts, and by setup) are described but not tested, and none was pre-registered. In arm A, 2023 made money (+$271.30) and 2024 lost $1,502.80; calls lost $86.40 and puts lost $1,145.10; the setups the book flags as strongest (A+) lost $2,497.10 while the others made $1,265.60. Findings read after a failed test are candidates for a new pre-registered test, not conclusions.
- The stretch from September 2024 is not counted: an earlier QS Research test had already looked at SPY there, and the re-look on it has not been run. A 120-session holdout is sealed.
The numbers: every trial's checks, metrics, curve and yearly results, and the provenance
1 published version · current eb80e21c4779634f, published 2026-11-13