Fading r/wallstreetbets Gain and YOLO posts and following Loss posts, 2018-2024
When a stock is named in a r/wallstreetbets post with a Gain, Loss, YOLO, DD or Meme flair, does fading the Gain, YOLO or Meme posts or following the Loss or DD posts make money after costs from the next open, at 1, 5 and 20 sessions, from 2018 to 2024?
No tradeable edge. Four of the 36 pre-registered trials pass on returns before costs: fading Gain, YOLO and Meme posts at 1 day (they beat SPY by +0.42%, +0.37% and +0.31%), and a balance-buy arm at 20 days (+11.31% on 92 events, with an entry-timing flaw). The 1-day gains are small: after a round-trip cost set by how much the stock trades and a short-borrow charge, the full-sample fade-Gain mean is -0.03%, and in the most liquid names it is +0.10% net with a 95% interval of -0.07% to +0.26%. A breakdown of 992 slices of the four headline arms found no pocket that clears the multiple-testing bar. The peak/bottom pattern is hindsight: Gain posts sit in the top 4 of 41 closes around the post at 2.48 times the random-date frequency for the same stocks under this rank rule (15.5% against 6.2%), but fading them from the next open earns only the small 1-day giveback.
Four of the 36 pre-registered trials pass on returns before costs: fading Gain, YOLO and Meme posts at 1 day, and a balance-buy arm on 92 events at 20 days. The cost and slice breakdown was written after the 36-trial result was seen and before any slice was computed; it covers the four headline arms (fade Gain, fade YOLO, fade Meme, buy Loss) and finds no cost-adjusted edge in any of them. The balance-buy pass is not cost-tested, rests on 92 events, and its entry can come before the posts that define the event, so it is not tradeable evidence. The fail is the after-cost verdict for the headline arms, not a claim that all 36 trials lose money.
Backtested by QS Research
Pre-registration
Written before any return was computed. Twelve arms were fixed in advance: fade Gain, follow Loss, fade YOLO, follow DD and fade Meme, each on all events and on spike days (at least three posts and three times the stock's own 20-day mean); two balance arms (fade a YOLO+Gain spike with few Loss posts; buy a Loss spike after a 10% fall); each at 1, 5 and 20 sessions, 36 trials in one family. An event is a stock named in a post on a US/Eastern day; entry is the first regular open after the earliest post; returns are measured against SPY, the S&P 500 fund. The bar was a Bonferroni-corrected lower bound above zero, positive without GME, AMC and BBBY, and positive in at least two of the three periods. Posts run 2018-2024. Amendment 1 added the Meme arm before any return; Amendment 2, written after the 36-trial result and before any slice, added costs by dollar-volume and market-cap tier and 992 slice trials.
Registered 2026-10-30Amendments
- 2026-10-30 Added the fade-Meme arm and its step-0 counts, before any return was computed. approved: Approved 2026-10-30, before any return
- 2026-10-30 Added the cost and slice breakdown of the four headline arms: 992 slice trials with dollar-volume costs and market-cap borrow. approved: Recorded 2026-10-30 after the 36-trial result was seen and before any slice was computed
Trials · 36 trials · 4 passed · judged at N = 36 trials; 2965 trials run in total
| Trial | Verdict | |
|---|---|---|
| balance buy, 1d | FAIL | counted |
| balance buy, 5d | FAIL | counted |
| balance buy, 20d | PASS | counted |
| balance fade, 1d | FAIL | counted |
| balance fade, 5d | FAIL | counted |
| balance fade, 20d | FAIL | counted |
| fade Gain, 1d | PASS | counted |
| fade Gain, 5d | FAIL | counted |
| fade Gain, 20d | FAIL | counted |
| fade Gain, spike, 1d | FAIL | counted |
| fade Gain, spike, 5d | FAIL | counted |
| fade Gain, spike, 20d | FAIL | counted |
| fade Meme, 1d | PASS | counted |
| fade Meme, 5d | FAIL | counted |
| fade Meme, 20d | FAIL | counted |
| fade Meme, spike, 1d | FAIL | counted |
| fade Meme, spike, 5d | FAIL | counted |
| fade Meme, spike, 20d | FAIL | counted |
| fade YOLO, 1d | PASS | counted |
| fade YOLO, 5d | FAIL | counted |
| fade YOLO, 20d | FAIL | counted |
| fade YOLO, spike, 1d | FAIL | counted |
| fade YOLO, spike, 5d | FAIL | counted |
| fade YOLO, spike, 20d | FAIL | counted |
| follow DD, 1d | FAIL | counted |
| follow DD, 5d | FAIL | counted |
| follow DD, 20d | FAIL | counted |
| follow DD, spike, 1d | FAIL | counted |
| follow DD, spike, 5d | FAIL | counted |
| follow DD, spike, 20d | FAIL | counted |
| follow Loss, 1d | FAIL | counted |
| follow Loss, 5d | FAIL | counted |
| follow Loss, 20d | FAIL | counted |
| follow Loss, spike, 1d | FAIL | counted |
| follow Loss, spike, 5d | FAIL | counted |
| follow Loss, spike, 20d | FAIL | counted |
Limitations
- The 2025-onward years are not covered: the archive that would supply them was stopped. The counted window is 2018-2024, and the Meme flair does not exist before 2019.
- The pre-registered bar was met by four arms before costs. The fail comes from the cost and slice breakdown, which was written after that result was seen and covers only the four headline arms; balance buy is not cost-tested.
- Costs are a model, not measured fills: a round trip by 20-day dollar-volume tier (5 to 250 basis points) plus, for the fades, borrow by market-cap tier (0.25% to 20% a year). Borrow is an assumption; no borrow-rate data was used.
- No data snapshot or software release is pinned in the result records, so the run cannot be replayed byte-for-byte from the published record.
- The balance arms take their entry from the earliest post of any flair on the ticker-day, which can come before the posts that define the event. This is lookahead; the balance-buy pass (92 events, a few large rebounds) is not tradeable evidence. It was disclosed, not re-run.
- The spike arms enter at the next open after the earliest post, which can be before the full day's post count is known, so they are not a clean real-time test. All spike arms fail.
- Exits are capped at the last session of the price data, so entries fewer than 20 sessions before that end are counted in the 20-session rows with a shorter holding. The run does not record how many.
- The peak/bottom timing test is descriptive and in hindsight. Its random-date baselines are 6.2% for Gain and 6.9% for Loss, below the 9.76% a tie-free top 4 of 41 would give, because tied closes fall out of the rank; the 2.48x and 1.25x lifts are against those baselines and may be inflated by ties.
- Of 238,391 events, 89,991 are not a US common stock on the date and are dropped (mostly SPY and QQQ posts, crypto and words the extraction kept); 2,707 more have no usable price; 145,693 are priced.
- Smaller departures from the pre-registration, disclosed and not re-run: the spike's 20-day mean allows fewer than 20 days of history; a post with both a DD mark and a Meme flair counts as DD; the benchmark is measured to the horizon even when a stock stopped trading earlier; the verdict code added a stricter ex-GME/AMC/BBBY interval condition that changes no verdict; in the slice breakdown a weekday market holiday is not classed as after the close.
- Events are equal-weighted; overlapping positions in the same stock are not netted, and there is no capacity limit.
The numbers: every trial's checks, metrics, curve and yearly results, and the provenance
1 published version · current 2602225b358b0365, published 2026-11-21