QSQuantSignals Research/Studies
Try FST free

← All studies

FAIL

The short-dated CHEAP and RICH cards: do they beat trading every name in the list?

When the options cards mark a same-day, next-day or weekly contract as cheap (implied volatility at or below realized) or rich (at least 1.10 times realized), does buying the cheap contract or selling a 1:4 credit spread on the rich one beat the same trade on every name in the list, after costs?

No. None of the six pre-registered trials passed, and every lower bound is below zero. Buying the list's cheap contract did no better than buying the same kind of contract on every name in the list. Same-day expiries: -3.9% a trade against -8.1% for all names, a +4.2-point difference with a one-sided lower bound of -0.6. Next-day: +5.1% against +5.2%, -0.1 point (-9.2). Weekly: +17.0% against +19.5%, -2.5 points (-15.3). The weekly gain is a 2023-24 rally that the all-names trade shared, not the ratio's: the median weekly buy lost its whole premium. Selling the list's rich 1:4 credit spread won 68% to 72% of trades, as a 1:4 spread is built to, but its average was no better than selling on every name: same-day -1.6% against -0.5% (-1.1 points, -19.5), next-day +4.6% against -2.6% (+7.3 points on 221 trades, -21.8), weekly -3.5% against -4.6% (+1.1 points, -10.3). Both positive rich differences rest on one session, 5 August 2024: without that session the next-day rich mean is -3.5% and the weekly rich mean is -5.2%. Most rich spreads used the nearest out-of-the-money fallback (90 of 117, 187 of 221, 1,108 of 1,365). The test covers 33 of the 35 names in the list from January 2023 to August 2024; the other two had no listed options in the window. The holdout stays sealed.

Backtested by QS Research

Pre-registration

Six trials were fixed before any quote was read, on the 35 names of the app's momentum list: buying a cheap contract and selling a rich 1:4 credit spread, each on same-day, next-day and weekly expiries (B0, S0, B1, S1, BW, SW), judged at a family of six with a one-sided 0.05/12 bound. At 10:00 ET each expiry is read from its calls and puts: at-the-money implied volatility is divided by the lower of one-year and three-month realized volatility for cheap (at or below 1.00) and by the higher for rich (at or above 1.10), with earnings reaction days removed. The side rule buys the cheaper 25-delta wing and sells the richer one when their implied volatilities differ by more than 2 points; otherwise it buys the at-the-money call and sells the 25-delta with the higher implied volatility. A cheap contract is bought at the ask plus $0.0065 a share and held to expiry; a rich contract is sold at the bid with the nearest further-out-of-the-money strike paying at least 1:4 of credit to maximum loss bought at its ask, both legs paying the commission, and when that strike has no such wing the nearest out-of-the-money strike on the same side that has one is sold instead. Trades settle at intrinsic on the expiry's official close, and a trade with a split in its life is left out. Every priced trade in the tenor counts in the baseline, whatever its ratio. A trial passes only if its mean return beats that baseline, the lower bound of a weekly-block bootstrap of the difference (10,000 resamples of entry weeks) is above zero, and its own mean is above zero. Entries run from 3 January 2023 to 30 August 2024, and a name enters a tenor only from the first session that tenor's expiry was listed. The 120 sessions after 9 November 2026 are a sealed holdout; a descriptive re-look window from September 2024 was listed in the pre-registration but not run.

Registered 2026-11-09

Amendments

A holdout sample is sealed: its results stay unread until the study is final.

Trials · 6 trials · 0 passed · judged at N = 6 trials; 2965 trials run in total

TrialVerdict
B0 · same-day expiry · CHEAP (ratio ≤ 1.00), buyFAILcounted
S0 · same-day expiry · RICH (ratio ≥ 1.10), 1:4 credit spreadFAILcounted
B1 · next-day expiry · CHEAP (ratio ≤ 1.00), buyFAILcounted
S1 · next-day expiry · RICH (ratio ≥ 1.10), 1:4 credit spreadFAILcounted
BW · weekly expiry · CHEAP (ratio ≤ 1.00), buyFAILcounted
SW · weekly expiry · RICH (ratio ≥ 1.10), 1:4 credit spreadFAILcounted

Limitations

The numbers: every trial's checks, metrics, curve and yearly results, and the provenance

2 published versions · current cd143659e2a96339, published 2026-11-21

Put these signals to work

This page is free. Members get the live version of every QS Research signal. FST, the QuantSignals trading agent, uses QS Research as its brain.

Join freeMeet FSTSee plans