Do cheap and rich option reads make money once the stock move is hedged out?
When a liquid US stock's at-the-money option looks cheap or rich against its recent realized volatility, does buying the cheap one or selling the rich one make money after bid/ask and after hedging out the stock exposure, and does holding the same picks to expiry do better?
No. Hedged, every cheap and rich read lost money at every tenor. Selling rich lost 0.27, 0.29 and 0.36 of the premium at near, mid and leap; buying cheap lost 0.16, 0.17 and 0.26, with every lower bound below zero, and each read did worse than the same trade on every liquid row. The only positive results are unhedged holds: cheap buys returned 0.53 times the premium at mid and 1.70 at leap, rich credit spreads returned 0.12 of maximum loss at leap, and the year-out at-the-money call returned 1.30 times its premium (the baseline returned 0.74), a difference of 0.56. Those are long-delta results on names that survived to 2026: the cheap and rich hold picks lose when delta-hedged, and the year-out rule was tested held only, so none of them is evidence of a hedged volatility edge. The mid cheap pass is marginal, the median cheap hold trade at mid and leap lost the whole premium and only 29-34% of those trades made money, and the 66 slice pockets are exploratory, all in the hold arm. A later survivorship-free re-run, a separate study, reproduces the original names exactly and then drops the cheap mid pass to a candidate pocket; the cheap leap still works but no longer beats every liquid leap row, while the year-out rule and the rich leap survive smaller (on the names that store adds, the year-out rule, the cheap leap and the rich leap have no edge). This is one in-sample decade with no holdout, and the held passes need a run on a sample that follows the pre-registration's earnings-coverage rule before they are read as the pre-registered result.
The study's own label is mixed: the result file marks four unhedged hold cells as clearing their bars on the original store (cheap buys at mid and leap, rich put spreads at leap, and the year-out at-the-money call at plain implied vol at most 0.90 times the lower realized read). None of the cheap and rich hold cells is a volatility result; the year-out rule was tested held only. All six delta-hedged cells fail, no alternative definition beats the current read, and the held passes are long-delta exposure on names that survived to 2026. The mid cheap pass is marginal (family lower bound +0.05); a later survivorship-free re-run, a separate study, drops it to a candidate pocket and says the cheap leap no longer beats every liquid leap row, while the year-out rule and the rich leap survive smaller (on the names that store adds, the year-out rule, the cheap leap and the rich leap have no edge). The rich leap pass is not better than selling every liquid leap row on the original store. Those four cells also ran on a sample that kept companies without earnings filings, against the pre-registration, so they are not counted here as passes: the published count is zero passes of 453 trials. The headline verdict is fail for the question asked; the 66 slice pockets are exploratory and are not passes.
Backtested by QS Research
Pre-registration
Written on 2026-11-18 before any code or hedged P&L, with one amendment before the run. The main test is six cells: the cheap and rich reads, each at a near (at least 30 days), mid (at least 120 days) and year-out (first January at least 365 days) expiry, bought or sold at the end-of-day quote, held to expiry and delta-hedged daily at the entry implied vol. Each cell is judged at a family of six with a month-block bootstrap: a pass needs a positive mean, a lower bound above zero, at least 300 trades on at least 36 entry months and a positive mean in both halves. Thirty further trials test three better definitions (a variance forecast, an implied-vol rank and a term-structure residual) by rank correlation and by picks. The amendment added six unhedged hold cells, one re-check of the earlier year-out rule and four catalyst comparisons. In total 453 trials were charged before any row was scored, including 406 exploratory slices. No holdout was reserved: every year from 2016 to 2026 is in-sample.
Registered 2026-11-18Amendments
- 2026-11-18 Before any row was scored: added the unhedged hold-to-expiry arm (six cells: cheap buys held, rich sells as defined-risk credit spreads) and the catalyst tags (earnings, FOMC, CPI, employment, election and the quarterly rebalance; no IPO calendar), with four catalyst comparisons. No data pin, main-test rule or bar changed. approved: Recorded before the counted run; no separate approval is recorded.
Trials · 453 trials · 0 passed · judged at N = 6 trials; 2965 trials run in total
| Trial | Verdict | |
|---|---|---|
| hunt-vol-reads:T1:cheap:leap | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T1:cheap:mid | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T1:cheap:near | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T1:rich:leap | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T1:rich:mid | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T1:rich:near | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T2:ic:D0:leap | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T2:ic:D0:mid | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T2:ic:D0:near | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T2:ic:D1:leap | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T2:ic:D1:mid | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T2:ic:D1:near | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T2:ic:D2:leap | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T2:ic:D2:mid | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T2:ic:D2:near | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T2:ic:D3:leap | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T2:ic:D3:mid | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T2:ic:D3:near | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T2:picks:D1:cheap:leap | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T2:picks:D1:cheap:mid | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T2:picks:D1:cheap:near | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T2:picks:D1:rich:leap | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T2:picks:D1:rich:mid | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T2:picks:D1:rich:near | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T2:picks:D2:cheap:leap | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T2:picks:D2:cheap:mid | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T2:picks:D2:cheap:near | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T2:picks:D2:rich:leap | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T2:picks:D2:rich:mid | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T2:picks:D2:rich:near | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T2:picks:D3:cheap:leap | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T2:picks:D3:cheap:mid | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T2:picks:D3:cheap:near | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T2:picks:D3:rich:leap | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T2:picks:D3:rich:mid | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T2:picks:D3:rich:near | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:cheap:leap:catalyst=no | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:cheap:leap:catalyst=yes | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:cheap:leap:dte=long-half | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:cheap:leap:dte=short-half | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:cheap:leap:election=no | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:cheap:leap:election=yes | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:cheap:leap:event=etf | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:cheap:leap:event=single-name | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:cheap:leap:fed=no | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:cheap:leap:fed=yes | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:cheap:leap:ivrv=0.80-0.90 | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:cheap:leap:ivrv=0.90-1.00 | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:cheap:leap:ivrv=<0.80 | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:cheap:leap:liquidity=spread2-5% | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:cheap:leap:liquidity=spread5-10% | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:cheap:leap:liquidity=spread<=2% | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:cheap:leap:rebalance=no | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:cheap:leap:rebalance=yes | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:cheap:leap:sector=construction | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:cheap:leap:sector=etf-or-nonfiler | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:cheap:leap:sector=finance | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:cheap:leap:sector=manufacturing | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:cheap:leap:sector=mining | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:cheap:leap:sector=retail | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:cheap:leap:sector=services | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:cheap:leap:sector=transport-utilities | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:cheap:leap:sector=unknown | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:cheap:leap:sector=wholesale | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:cheap:leap:strike=atm | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:cheap:leap:strike=wing | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:cheap:leap:vix=15-20 | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:cheap:leap:vix=20-30 | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:cheap:leap:vix=<15 | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:cheap:leap:vix=>30 | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:cheap:mid:catalyst=no | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:cheap:mid:catalyst=yes | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:cheap:mid:dte=long-half | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:cheap:mid:dte=short-half | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:cheap:mid:election=no | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:cheap:mid:election=yes | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:cheap:mid:event=etf | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:cheap:mid:event=single-name | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:cheap:mid:fed=no | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:cheap:mid:fed=yes | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:cheap:mid:ivrv=0.80-0.90 | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:cheap:mid:ivrv=0.90-1.00 | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:cheap:mid:ivrv=<0.80 | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:cheap:mid:liquidity=spread2-5% | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:cheap:mid:liquidity=spread5-10% | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:cheap:mid:liquidity=spread<=2% | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:cheap:mid:rebalance=no | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:cheap:mid:rebalance=yes | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:cheap:mid:sector=construction | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:cheap:mid:sector=etf-or-nonfiler | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:cheap:mid:sector=finance | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:cheap:mid:sector=manufacturing | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:cheap:mid:sector=mining | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:cheap:mid:sector=retail | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:cheap:mid:sector=services | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:cheap:mid:sector=transport-utilities | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:cheap:mid:sector=unknown | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:cheap:mid:sector=wholesale | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:cheap:mid:strike=atm | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:cheap:mid:strike=wing | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:cheap:mid:vix=15-20 | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:cheap:mid:vix=20-30 | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:cheap:mid:vix=<15 | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:cheap:mid:vix=>30 | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:cheap:near:catalyst=no | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:cheap:near:catalyst=yes | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:cheap:near:dte=long-half | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:cheap:near:dte=short-half | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:cheap:near:election=no | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:cheap:near:election=yes | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:cheap:near:event=etf | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:cheap:near:event=event | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:cheap:near:event=no-event | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:cheap:near:fed=no | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:cheap:near:fed=yes | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:cheap:near:ivrv=0.80-0.90 | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:cheap:near:ivrv=0.90-1.00 | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:cheap:near:ivrv=<0.80 | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:cheap:near:liquidity=spread2-5% | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:cheap:near:liquidity=spread5-10% | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:cheap:near:liquidity=spread<=2% | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:cheap:near:rebalance=no | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:cheap:near:rebalance=yes | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:cheap:near:sector=construction | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:cheap:near:sector=etf-or-nonfiler | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:cheap:near:sector=finance | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:cheap:near:sector=manufacturing | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:cheap:near:sector=mining | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:cheap:near:sector=retail | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:cheap:near:sector=services | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:cheap:near:sector=transport-utilities | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:cheap:near:sector=unknown | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:cheap:near:sector=wholesale | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:cheap:near:strike=atm | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:cheap:near:strike=wing | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:cheap:near:vix=15-20 | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:cheap:near:vix=20-30 | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:cheap:near:vix=<15 | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:cheap:near:vix=>30 | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:rich:leap:catalyst=no | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:rich:leap:catalyst=yes | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:rich:leap:dte=long-half | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:rich:leap:dte=short-half | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:rich:leap:election=no | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:rich:leap:election=yes | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:rich:leap:event=etf | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:rich:leap:event=single-name | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:rich:leap:fed=no | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:rich:leap:fed=yes | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:rich:leap:ivrv=1.10-1.25 | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:rich:leap:ivrv=1.25-1.50 | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:rich:leap:ivrv=>1.50 | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:rich:leap:liquidity=spread2-5% | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:rich:leap:liquidity=spread5-10% | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:rich:leap:liquidity=spread<=2% | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:rich:leap:rebalance=no | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:rich:leap:rebalance=yes | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:rich:leap:sector=construction | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:rich:leap:sector=etf-or-nonfiler | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:rich:leap:sector=finance | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:rich:leap:sector=manufacturing | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:rich:leap:sector=mining | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:rich:leap:sector=retail | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:rich:leap:sector=services | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:rich:leap:sector=transport-utilities | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:rich:leap:sector=unknown | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:rich:leap:sector=wholesale | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:rich:leap:strike=wing | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:rich:leap:vix=15-20 | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:rich:leap:vix=20-30 | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:rich:leap:vix=<15 | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:rich:leap:vix=>30 | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:rich:mid:catalyst=no | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:rich:mid:catalyst=yes | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:rich:mid:dte=long-half | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:rich:mid:dte=short-half | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:rich:mid:election=no | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:rich:mid:election=yes | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:rich:mid:event=etf | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:rich:mid:event=single-name | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:rich:mid:fed=no | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:rich:mid:fed=yes | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:rich:mid:ivrv=1.10-1.25 | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:rich:mid:ivrv=1.25-1.50 | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:rich:mid:ivrv=>1.50 | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:rich:mid:liquidity=spread2-5% | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:rich:mid:liquidity=spread5-10% | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:rich:mid:liquidity=spread<=2% | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:rich:mid:rebalance=no | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:rich:mid:rebalance=yes | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:rich:mid:sector=construction | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:rich:mid:sector=etf-or-nonfiler | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:rich:mid:sector=finance | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:rich:mid:sector=manufacturing | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:rich:mid:sector=mining | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:rich:mid:sector=retail | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:rich:mid:sector=services | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:rich:mid:sector=transport-utilities | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:rich:mid:sector=unknown | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:rich:mid:sector=wholesale | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:rich:mid:strike=wing | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:rich:mid:vix=15-20 | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:rich:mid:vix=20-30 | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:rich:mid:vix=<15 | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:rich:mid:vix=>30 | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:rich:near:catalyst=no | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:rich:near:catalyst=yes | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:rich:near:dte=long-half | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:rich:near:dte=short-half | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:rich:near:election=no | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:rich:near:election=yes | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:rich:near:event=etf | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:rich:near:event=event | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:rich:near:event=no-event | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:rich:near:fed=no | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:rich:near:fed=yes | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:rich:near:ivrv=1.10-1.25 | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:rich:near:ivrv=1.25-1.50 | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:rich:near:ivrv=>1.50 | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:rich:near:liquidity=spread2-5% | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:rich:near:liquidity=spread5-10% | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:rich:near:liquidity=spread<=2% | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:rich:near:rebalance=no | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:rich:near:rebalance=yes | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:rich:near:sector=construction | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:rich:near:sector=etf-or-nonfiler | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:rich:near:sector=finance | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:rich:near:sector=manufacturing | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:rich:near:sector=mining | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:rich:near:sector=retail | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:rich:near:sector=services | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:rich:near:sector=transport-utilities | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:rich:near:sector=unknown | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:rich:near:sector=wholesale | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:rich:near:strike=wing | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:rich:near:vix=15-20 | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:rich:near:vix=20-30 | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:rich:near:vix=<15 | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hedged:rich:near:vix=>30 | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:cheap:leap:catalyst=no | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:cheap:leap:catalyst=yes | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:cheap:leap:dte=long-half | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:cheap:leap:dte=short-half | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:cheap:leap:election=no | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:cheap:leap:election=yes | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:cheap:leap:event=etf | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:cheap:leap:event=single-name | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:cheap:leap:fed=no | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:cheap:leap:fed=yes | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:cheap:leap:ivrv=0.80-0.90 | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:cheap:leap:ivrv=0.90-1.00 | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:cheap:leap:ivrv=<0.80 | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:cheap:leap:liquidity=spread2-5% | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:cheap:leap:liquidity=spread5-10% | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:cheap:leap:liquidity=spread<=2% | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:cheap:leap:rebalance=no | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:cheap:leap:rebalance=yes | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:cheap:leap:sector=construction | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:cheap:leap:sector=etf-or-nonfiler | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:cheap:leap:sector=finance | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:cheap:leap:sector=manufacturing | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:cheap:leap:sector=mining | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:cheap:leap:sector=retail | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:cheap:leap:sector=services | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:cheap:leap:sector=transport-utilities | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:cheap:leap:sector=unknown | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:cheap:leap:sector=wholesale | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:cheap:leap:strike=atm | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:cheap:leap:strike=wing | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:cheap:leap:vix=15-20 | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:cheap:leap:vix=20-30 | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:cheap:leap:vix=<15 | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:cheap:leap:vix=>30 | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:cheap:mid:catalyst=no | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:cheap:mid:catalyst=yes | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:cheap:mid:dte=long-half | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:cheap:mid:dte=short-half | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:cheap:mid:election=no | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:cheap:mid:election=yes | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:cheap:mid:event=etf | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:cheap:mid:event=single-name | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:cheap:mid:fed=no | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:cheap:mid:fed=yes | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:cheap:mid:ivrv=0.80-0.90 | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:cheap:mid:ivrv=0.90-1.00 | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:cheap:mid:ivrv=<0.80 | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:cheap:mid:liquidity=spread2-5% | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:cheap:mid:liquidity=spread5-10% | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:cheap:mid:liquidity=spread<=2% | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:cheap:mid:rebalance=no | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:cheap:mid:rebalance=yes | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:cheap:mid:sector=construction | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:cheap:mid:sector=etf-or-nonfiler | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:cheap:mid:sector=finance | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:cheap:mid:sector=manufacturing | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:cheap:mid:sector=mining | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:cheap:mid:sector=retail | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:cheap:mid:sector=services | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:cheap:mid:sector=transport-utilities | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:cheap:mid:sector=unknown | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:cheap:mid:sector=wholesale | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:cheap:mid:strike=atm | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:cheap:mid:strike=wing | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:cheap:mid:vix=15-20 | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:cheap:mid:vix=20-30 | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:cheap:mid:vix=<15 | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:cheap:mid:vix=>30 | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:cheap:near:catalyst=no | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:cheap:near:catalyst=yes | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:cheap:near:dte=long-half | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:cheap:near:dte=short-half | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:cheap:near:election=no | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:cheap:near:election=yes | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:cheap:near:event=etf | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:cheap:near:event=event | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:cheap:near:event=no-event | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:cheap:near:fed=no | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:cheap:near:fed=yes | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:cheap:near:ivrv=0.80-0.90 | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:cheap:near:ivrv=0.90-1.00 | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:cheap:near:ivrv=<0.80 | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:cheap:near:liquidity=spread2-5% | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:cheap:near:liquidity=spread5-10% | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:cheap:near:liquidity=spread<=2% | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:cheap:near:rebalance=no | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:cheap:near:rebalance=yes | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:cheap:near:sector=construction | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:cheap:near:sector=etf-or-nonfiler | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:cheap:near:sector=finance | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:cheap:near:sector=manufacturing | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:cheap:near:sector=mining | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:cheap:near:sector=retail | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:cheap:near:sector=services | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:cheap:near:sector=transport-utilities | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:cheap:near:sector=unknown | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:cheap:near:sector=wholesale | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:cheap:near:strike=atm | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:cheap:near:strike=wing | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:cheap:near:vix=15-20 | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:cheap:near:vix=20-30 | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:cheap:near:vix=<15 | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:cheap:near:vix=>30 | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:rich:leap:catalyst=no | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:rich:leap:catalyst=yes | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:rich:leap:dte=long-half | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:rich:leap:dte=short-half | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:rich:leap:election=no | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:rich:leap:election=yes | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:rich:leap:event=etf | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:rich:leap:event=single-name | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:rich:leap:fed=no | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:rich:leap:fed=yes | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:rich:leap:ivrv=1.10-1.25 | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:rich:leap:ivrv=1.25-1.50 | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:rich:leap:ivrv=>1.50 | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:rich:leap:liquidity=spread2-5% | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:rich:leap:liquidity=spread5-10% | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:rich:leap:liquidity=spread<=2% | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:rich:leap:rebalance=no | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:rich:leap:rebalance=yes | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:rich:leap:sector=construction | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:rich:leap:sector=etf-or-nonfiler | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:rich:leap:sector=finance | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:rich:leap:sector=manufacturing | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:rich:leap:sector=mining | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:rich:leap:sector=retail | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:rich:leap:sector=services | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:rich:leap:sector=transport-utilities | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:rich:leap:sector=unknown | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:rich:leap:sector=wholesale | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:rich:leap:strike=wing | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:rich:leap:vix=15-20 | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:rich:leap:vix=20-30 | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:rich:leap:vix=<15 | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:rich:leap:vix=>30 | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:rich:mid:catalyst=no | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:rich:mid:catalyst=yes | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:rich:mid:dte=long-half | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:rich:mid:dte=short-half | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:rich:mid:election=no | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:rich:mid:election=yes | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:rich:mid:event=etf | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:rich:mid:event=single-name | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:rich:mid:fed=no | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:rich:mid:fed=yes | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:rich:mid:ivrv=1.10-1.25 | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:rich:mid:ivrv=1.25-1.50 | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:rich:mid:ivrv=>1.50 | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:rich:mid:liquidity=spread2-5% | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:rich:mid:liquidity=spread5-10% | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:rich:mid:liquidity=spread<=2% | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:rich:mid:rebalance=no | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:rich:mid:rebalance=yes | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:rich:mid:sector=construction | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:rich:mid:sector=etf-or-nonfiler | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:rich:mid:sector=finance | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:rich:mid:sector=manufacturing | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:rich:mid:sector=mining | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:rich:mid:sector=retail | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:rich:mid:sector=services | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:rich:mid:sector=transport-utilities | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:rich:mid:sector=unknown | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:rich:mid:sector=wholesale | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:rich:mid:strike=wing | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:rich:mid:vix=15-20 | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:rich:mid:vix=20-30 | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:rich:mid:vix=<15 | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:rich:mid:vix=>30 | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:rich:near:catalyst=no | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:rich:near:catalyst=yes | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:rich:near:dte=long-half | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:rich:near:dte=short-half | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:rich:near:election=no | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:rich:near:election=yes | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:rich:near:event=etf | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:rich:near:event=event | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:rich:near:event=no-event | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:rich:near:fed=no | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:rich:near:fed=yes | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:rich:near:ivrv=1.10-1.25 | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:rich:near:ivrv=1.25-1.50 | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:rich:near:ivrv=>1.50 | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:rich:near:liquidity=spread2-5% | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:rich:near:liquidity=spread5-10% | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:rich:near:liquidity=spread<=2% | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:rich:near:rebalance=no | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:rich:near:rebalance=yes | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:rich:near:sector=construction | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:rich:near:sector=etf-or-nonfiler | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:rich:near:sector=finance | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:rich:near:sector=manufacturing | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:rich:near:sector=mining | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:rich:near:sector=retail | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:rich:near:sector=services | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:rich:near:sector=transport-utilities | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:rich:near:sector=unknown | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:rich:near:sector=wholesale | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:rich:near:strike=wing | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:rich:near:vix=15-20 | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:rich:near:vix=20-30 | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:rich:near:vix=<15 | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T3:hold:rich:near:vix=>30 | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T6:hold:cheap:leap | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T6:hold:cheap:mid | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T6:hold:cheap:near | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T6:hold:rich:leap | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T6:hold:rich:mid | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T6:hold:rich:near | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T6:t7-recheck:leap-atm-call-plain<=0.90:hold | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T7:keyq:cheap-catalyst-minus-none:hedged:near | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T7:keyq:cheap-catalyst-minus-none:hold:near | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T7:keyq:rich-none-minus-catalyst:hedged:near | RESULT | counted |
| hunt-vol-reads:T7:keyq:rich-none-minus-catalyst:hold:near | RESULT | counted |
| Rich as a sell signal (vol) | FAIL | not counted |
| Cheap as a buy signal (vol) | FAIL | not counted |
| Cheap, held (hold arm) | RESULT | not counted |
| Rich, held as a put spread | RESULT | not counted |
| The tested buy rule (year-out ATM call, plain IV ≤ 0.90× lower RV), held | RESULT | not counted |
| Better cheap/rich definitions (HAR, IV rank, term-structure residual) | FAIL | not counted |
| Catalysts (key question) | RESULT | not counted |
| Heavy flow and its side | RESULT | not counted |
| The hunt's live record | RESULT | not counted |
Limitations
- Survivorship: the option store holds the 557 names that were liquid in November 2026; companies that later delisted are absent. Every held long-delta result is flattered. A later, separate survivorship-free re-run on 1,846 names reproduces this store exactly and then finds: the year-out rule survives at +0.92 (lower bound +0.48) and still beats every year-out call (+0.35, lower bound +0.16); the cheap leap hold works at +1.18 but no longer beats every liquid leap row (incremental +0.21, lower bound -0.11); the cheap mid hold drops to a candidate pocket (+0.42, family lower bound -0.02); the rich leap hold works at +0.10. On the names added by that store the year-out rule alone has no edge (n 645, mean -0.12, median -1.00), the cheap leap hold is -0.45 and the rich leap hold is +0.01 (neither works); the pooled numbers are carried by the survivors. This entry reports only the original store; read its four passes with that later result beside them.
- Companies without an earnings filing were kept on the plain realized read. 162 of the 557 names have no earnings filing at all, and at least 25 are operating companies or ADRs, not funds (for example TSM, ASML, BABA, PDD, SPOT, ARM and NU). The pre-registration said a single name with no filing in the prior 400 sessions is dropped; these were kept and counted in the fund/non-filer bucket. The four held passes are not on the pre-registered sample until a corrected run is made.
- The four held cells are unhedged: the cheap and rich hold picks lose when delta-hedged, while the year-out rule was tested held only. The cheap and rich passes are stock direction, not volatility pricing, and the year-out rule is not evidence of a hedged volatility edge. The median cheap hold trade at mid and leap lost the whole premium and only 29% (mid) and 34% (leap) of trades made money; the mean is carried by a few large winners. The mid pass is marginal (family lower bound +0.05) and a later survivorship-free re-run drops it to a candidate pocket. The cheap mid read is not better than buying every liquid row (incremental +0.05, band includes zero); the rich leap read is worse than selling every liquid leap row (incremental -0.035, band below zero). On the original store, only the cheap leap read adds (incremental +0.48, lower bound +0.05).
- The year-out rule is not an independent replication and is not out-of-sample. It is tested on the hunt's year-out expiry, not the earlier test's 300-450 day window; the same decade and overlapping names are used, and the earlier test's 2022-on holdout is inside this study's window. Its +1.30 is a fraction of the premium, not a dollar amount per option, and the earlier test's per-option figure is a different unit.
- The 66 slice pockets are exploratory and are the same held direction effect cut finer; they are not separate leads and not passes. The signed result labels those slice rows 'works'; the study does not count them as passes, and a corrected result must label them as candidate pockets.
- No holdout was reserved: the whole 2016-2026 window, including the 2022-on years that were another study's holdout, is in-sample for this study. One market regime, mostly rising.
- Monthly entries only, at end-of-day quotes, held to expiry: no intraday entry, no intermediate marks, no take-profit or stop. Fills are the quoted bid/ask plus $0.0065 a share; the hedge pays 1 basis point of notional traded and is rebalanced at daily closes at the entry implied vol. Real fills and discrete-hedging noise can differ.
- The option store holds 557 chains, not the 558 the pre-registration states. Price files end between 2026-10-29 and 2026-11-13 (125 chains to 11-13, 412 to 11-04, 20 to 10-29); no monthly expiry falls in that range, so no trade's open or settled status changes.
- The per-row output of the run is not committed; only aggregates of it (the share of each leg and the hedged result by realized-to-implied bucket) are, with the per-row file's content hash. The report's data list names only the option quotes; the stock prices, earnings dates, VIX and sector data and the macro calendar are pinned in the study's result record but not in the report's data list, so a reproduction from the published provenance lacks them. The flow and live-record summaries were made by scripts that are kept only in the study's history.
- The flow side is untested: no historical option trade prints across the study's names, so the study judges the pricing read on every liquid row, not the hunt's top-15 list. The seven-day flow summary is descriptive only. The live record is seven sessions, nothing settled, and is not a trial. IPO catalysts were not tested because no historical large-IPO calendar exists.
- The 453 recorded trials carry no per-trial verdict, so this page counts zero passes; the four held cells the result file marks as clearing their bars are described in the summary and limitations, not counted as passes.
- The side rule buys the 25-delta call for 63% to 76% of cheap picks and sells the 25-delta put for 93% to 97% of rich picks, so the held results are long delta.
- The earnings event tag and the catalyst split use the date the company actually filed, and a report filed after the close on the expiry day is tagged as an event although its reaction falls after expiry. A trader at the entry close may not have known that exact date, so the event split and the four catalyst comparisons describe what happened, not a signal known in advance. The FOMC, CPI, employment and election dates are scheduled.
- The code applies a stricter rule than the pre-registration for a main cell's candidate pocket (at least 100 trades on 24 months); no verdict changes.
The numbers: every trial's checks, metrics, curve and yearly results, and the provenance
1 published version · current ade3ee25f5b08dea, published 2026-11-21