QSQuantSignals Research/Studies
Try FST free

← All studies

FAIL

A long-dated call held alone versus the same call with a one-month call sold against it every month

Does selling a one-month call against a year-out, deep in-the-money call every month beat simply holding that long call, after real bid/ask quotes and commissions?

No. Selling a one-month call against a held LEAPS (a long-dated call) did worse than holding it in every test. Across 1,897 trades on 20 large, liquid US names (17 stocks and 3 index ETFs), entered from 2016 to 2025 and held about a year, the overlay gave back 29.2% of the premium paid, with a recorded 98.75% interval of -33.8% to -24.2%. The subset where the short-expiry at-the-money implied volatility was above trailing realized volatility at entry lost 28.1% (-34.4% to -22.2%). The other two pre-registered variants lost 19.8% and 38.2%, and the two extra subsets those runs computed lost 19.1% and 36.8%; all six trials fail. The overlay helped only when the stock rose little or fell (+2.2% in the bottom third of stock returns) and hurt most when it rose (-69.7% in the top third). It lost in 9 of the 10 entry years; the only positive year was 2021 (+8.4%). Holding the LEAPS alone averaged +80.1% (median +54.9%), but that is 20 large names in a strong decade, not evidence of an edge.

Backtested by QS Research

Pre-registration

Written on 2026-10-31, before any code or priced trade. One trade per name per monthly snapshot: buy the listed call nearest 0.80 delta with 300 to 450 days to expiry at the ask, hold it to expiry, and compare it with the same call plus a one-month call sold at the 0.30-delta strike at the bid on the entry date and again each month after the previous short expires. Each leg pays $0.65 a contract; expiries settle at intrinsic on the closing price; returns are measured on the long call's premium. The tests fixed in advance were the all-trade mean and the subset where the short-expiry at-the-money implied volatility was above trailing 60-session realized volatility at entry, plus the same all-trade mean at 0.80/0.20 and 0.70/0.30. A test passes only if the lower bound of its 98.75% bootstrap interval, clustered by entry date with 2,000 resamples, is above zero. No holdout was reserved. A post-run erratum records that six trials were charged, not four (each variant also computed the implied-volatility subset), and that all six count; the stricter six-test bar is 99.17%. The recorded intervals are the original four-test 98.75% bounds.

Registered 2026-10-31

Amendments

Trials · 6 trials · 0 passed · judged at N = 6 trials; 2965 trials run in total

TrialVerdict
T1: all tradesFAILcounted
T2: short IV > trailing RVFAILcounted
0.80 long / 0.20 short: all tradesFAILcounted
0.80 long / 0.20 short: implied vol above trailing realized volFAILcounted
0.70 long / 0.30 short: all tradesFAILcounted
0.70 long / 0.30 short: implied vol above trailing realized volFAILcounted

Limitations

The numbers: every trial's checks, metrics, curve and yearly results, and the provenance

2 published versions · current b9438fb3b772c7fd, published 2026-11-21

Put these signals to work

This page is free. Members get the live version of every QS Research signal. FST, the QuantSignals trading agent, uses QS Research as its brain.

Join freeMeet FSTSee plans